Best Crib Mattresses For Picky Moms


Shopping around for the best crib mattress? You’ve come to the right place. The mattress is equally important to the crib so you want to make sure you are getting the right one for your baby. If you’re a first-time mom, choosing a baby mattress can be a tricky task with so many options around. It’s not enough that it’s soft or pretty. You should look for one that gives long-term comfort. Luckily, here’s a list of the best crib mattresses on the market today. Check their unique features so you can easily decide which one is perfect for your baby.

Top 12 Crib Mattresses of 2020 Reviewed

We listed these mattresses as the best for a variety of reasons. We took note of the safety, the materials they were made of and many other important features.

1. LA Baby Waterproof Portable Mini Crib Mattress

LA Baby Waterproof Portable Mini Crib Mattress

If you prefer buying a smaller crib, the LA Baby Waterproof Portable Mattress makes a wonderful choice. It is made from high-density polyfiber and stain-resistant waterproof outer fabric that’s hypo-allergenic, anti-microbial and non-toxic. The vinyl cover keeps the mattress fresh.

2. Dream on Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

Dream on Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

This lightweight baby mattress features 80 sturdy interwoven heat-tempered steel coils which offer strong support to your baby’s developing bones. The Dream on Me Spring Crib Mattress is consists of hypo-allergenic protective polyurethane foam that gives lavish comfort, plus a triple-laminated waterproof cover.

3. Graco Premium Foam Mattress

Graco Premium Foam Mattress

This mattress perfectly fits in any full-sized crib and toddler bed. It features a high-quality, breathable foam that has anti-microbial properties. The Graco Premium Mattress is initially compressed in a lightweight box so it’s so convenient and easy to travel. You will be amazed to see the mattress expands in full size after unpacking it.

4. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib Mattress

Lightweight and water-resistant, this mattress also fits any full-sized cribs. It is comprised of thermo-bonded polyester filling and core that offers firm support.  The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams Mattress is GREENGUARD certified, which means it meets the standards for low-chemical emissions.

5. BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Crib and Toddler Mattress

BeautySleep SlumberTime Naturally Crib and Toddler Mattress

This brand features soy-enhanced foam core for high-quality firmness and is specifically designed for both infants and toddlers. If you’re looking for a healthy alternative for your child’s room, you can be sure about BeautySleep SlumberTime Crib Mattress.

6. My First Crib Mattress

My First Crib Mattress

My First Crib Mattress features a premium memory foam that provides a comfortable and restful slumber. It has removable and washable plush velour cover that is soft to your baby’s skin and is initially vacuum-packed for easy transportation.

7. Simmons Kids BeautySleep Woodland Dreams

Simmons Kids BeautySleep Woodland Dreams

Thermo-bonded polyester fiber core for supreme strength, 3D microclimate border for better air circulation, and square corners for easy fitting to the crib. Despite all the heavy features, the Simmons Kids BeautySleep Mattress is lightweight for easy changing.

8. Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam-Core Infant/Toddler Crib Mattress

This award-winning innovative baby mattress uses renewable soybeans for firmness, supporting children from infant to toddler years. The Sealy Soybean Mattress also features an embossed waterproof and stain-resistant cover that is secured through lock-stitch binding, ensuring that no liquid seeps through the foam inside.

9. Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers

Simmons Kids Beautyrest Beginnings Sleepy Whispers

Simmons Kids Crib Mattress features a dual-purpose design that provides an ideal firmness for the newborn and a soft, comfortable cover for a toddler. Inside are 231 luxury pocketed coils for superior support and a reinforced border protection so you can be sure this mattress will last for a long, long time. The woven cover is water and stain-resistant too.

10. Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress

Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib and Toddler Mattress

Designed for a tranquil slumber, this crib mattress features 120 highly durable innerspring coils and ortho-insulated layer for support. The foam of Serta Tranquility Eco Mattress is made from convoluted cotton layers on the toddler side for added comfort, wrapped in a waterproof vinyl cover to keep the moisture and stain away.

11. Colgate Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib Mattress

Colgate Dual Firmness Eco-Friendlier Crib mattress

Certified organic – this orthopedic-style crib mattress is 6-inch thick, lightweight, and can fit to a standard-sized baby and toddler cribs, featuring a dual-firm design to suit your child’s comfort needs. The organic cotton used in Colgate Eco Dual Firmness Mattress has a texture that is closest to a baby’s skin and has a waterproof backing.

12. Graco Natural Organic Crib Mattress

Graco Natural Organic Crib Mattress

Made from high-quality soybean oil foam and other organic materials, Graco Organic Mattress is made from extra-firm dye-free foam and comes with a removable and hand-washable cover that has a waterproof lining. The mattress is anti-static and anti-microbial.

How To Choose A Crib Mattress

Like choosing a crib, choosing a mattress really depends on your own needs and preferences. Keen examination of the product is the key so you end up buying the right one for your baby. Since your baby will be spending most of the time on his mattress, it is worthy to take time exploring your options. There are many mattresses available today, for sure. But don’t be overwhelmed. With these helpful tips, along with the list of the best crib mattresses, you know you’re on the right path.

What makes a good mattress

Baby mattresses are not simply a smaller version of adult mattresses. They have unique features that are specially designed for the growing infant. Generally, they are firmer than ordinary adult mattresses in order to keep the baby secure and support their developing bones. You want to make sure the mattress you’re buying is rated for infant use.

Do your research

Not all infant mattresses are the same – they could be foam, innerspring, or organic. Take time to research about the pros and cons of each one so you can decide which one is most suitable for your baby. Generally, foams cost less, are lightweight, and can either be organic or not. However, they are less durable, may lack edge support, and prone to indentations. Coil mattresses, also called ‘innerspring’, tend to be more durable, have good edge support, long-lasting, and offer better support. But they are usually more expensive, heavier than foam, and if you’ve got a low-quality cover, it can lead to exposed, uncomfortable coils.


It’s sensible to buy the crib first before you start shopping around for the mattress. Even though most baby mattresses fit standard-sized cribs, it’s always a great idea to make sure that the measurements of the two products perfectly match. A good mattress snugs perfectly against the frame so you may consider a mattress that has square corners.


You want extreme comfort for your baby, especially during his first few months as an infant. Don’t buy a mattress with insufficient vent.

Vents allow air circulation which is needed for preventing odor, as well as mildew and mold buildup. Check for reinforced holes along the sides. This suggests good venting.

Another thing, check if the mattress is made from materials that are generally considered safe for your baby. More and more moms are choosing organic, eco-friendly mattresses as some research suggests that many of the chemicals used in manufacturing household products may pose potential health hazards, especially to children. A good mattress would also have very helpful features, like being water-resistant, antibacterial, and hypoallergenic.

Third-party certifications

Some brands would claim that they are tested for safety and being eco-friendly, for instance. Believe it if the certifications were provided by a third-party. Products in the United States should meet specific safety standards, such as those given by the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSP) and the American Society for Testing and Materials. Not all certifications boasting ‘organic’ means the entire product is made from organic materials. If you’re really into buying organic mattresses, check the label to see if it is marked “100% organic”.